16 October 2026
To:
The Office of the Executive Mayor, City of Johannesburg
The Board of the Friends of the Johannesburg Art Gallery
The Johannesburg Art Gallery holds one of the most significant public art collections on the African continent, held in trust for the people of this city. Today that collection is housed in a building that leaks, in conditions that threaten it, without a secure path to safety or a shared picture of what this institution should become. This letter sets out what we believe is needed to change that.
It offers an alternative to the costly and paralysing legal contestation between the City and two external organisations, the Friends of the Johannesburg Art Gallery and the Johannesburg Heritage Foundation, and sits alongside a public statement on the resignation of the independent members of the Art Gallery Committee, which can be found here.
What the institution actually needs
The problems facing the Gallery are not, at their heart, a dispute about which committee holds authority, or even only about moving artworks out of harm’s way. They run deeper, historically and structurally, and on most of them the parties substantially agree.
As a sub-unit of a directorate within the City administration, with no independent legal form of its own, the Gallery cannot easily raise or manage the resources or procure the services a turnaround requires, determine its own staffing, effectively communicate its programming to the public, or form and sustain the external partnerships its future will depend on — all things that successful museums elsewhere do as a matter of course. These are not failures of the people who work there, many of whom have shown real dedication in impossible circumstances. These are structural problems. Any serious attempt to secure the Gallery’s future will have to make the administrative machinery of the City an asset rather than an obstacle, and enhance the ability of the City’s Arts, Culture and Heritage Directorate and the Gallery’s staff to deliver on a shared vision, working with external partners.
What should happen now
We set out what we think are a set of steps and measures that run from the immediate to the long-term. They are connected, none is sufficient on its own.
End the litigation: This lies first with The Friends of the JAG and the Johannesburg Heritage Foundation who brought the proceedings against the City and can withdraw them. Expensive, adversarial proceedings have diverted time and money away from addressing the real challenges facing the Gallery. Both parties should agree to stand the current proceedings down in favour of an independently facilitated process capable of resolving the underlying disputes.
Put the relationship between the City and the Gallery’s supporters into writing: Clear, binding agreements — covering how the City works with external partners such as the Friends and others, how contributions are raised, managed and accounted for, and how disputes are resolved — would enable the goodwill and funding offered to this institution to actually reach it, rather than stalling indefinitely on an entrenched dynamic of mutual mistrust.
Secure the collection: Considerable public money and action has already gone into preparing host sites near the Gallery. Available partnerships and resources should be mobilised to address any outstanding issues with these facilities and ensure that the work can now be completed — alongside the full digitisation, appraisal and audit of the collection.
Arrest the physical decline of the building: The Office of the Mayor should champion the process of raising the internal and external resources required to conclude the design and planning phase, and move into implementation of the comprehensive renovation and upgrade. Where emergency measures are required in the very immediate term, these should be undertaken under the supervision of appropriately qualified professionals. To the greatest degree possible, there should be continuity of service provision so as to avoid piecemeal and fragmented interventions across the short and medium term. Ongoing maintenance needs should not be treated as a residual item competing with other municipal priorities.
Resolve the governance and the institutional model through proper process, not contest: This begins with purpose. The Gallery's building, location, collection and historical programme were shaped around the needs of a wealthy elite within a minority of the population. How it might speak both to its immediate urban context and to Johannesburg at large remains unresolved, and answering that means rethinking the physical infrastructure itself and projecting the collection and programming into a decentralised civic infrastructure that meets people where they are.
This should be followed by decisions on how the Gallery sits within the City's administrative machinery, how comparable metropolitan museums elsewhere in the world govern, fund and manage themselves, and who, across a relevant range of interests and expertise, should serve. It extends to management too: the Chief Curator's role, barely changed since 1913, still combines strategic leadership, operations and curation; comparable institutions routinely separate these. Comprehensive, independent legal advice should be sought to reconcile this new design with the Deed of Donation (the founding document that brought the Committee into existence in 1913) and stress-test it against the Deed's requirements, and against the constitutional and municipal-law framework now governing the institution, so that what emerges is durable and fit for purpose.
How this should be done
None of this will be resolved by the parties acting alone, or against one another. What is required is a convening authority independent of the contest itself, acceptable to all sides and with the standing to hold them to the process and its outcomes. The process should bring into one room the Office of the Executive Mayor, the Arts, Culture and Heritage Directorate, the Johannesburg Development Agency, the Anglo American Johannesburg Centenary Trust, the Friends of the Johannesburg Art Gallery and the Johannesburg Heritage Foundation. It should be professionally facilitated, and conducted as a negotiation aimed at achieving a compact, without lawyers in the room.
The reconstitution of the Committee in the wake of our resignation represents an immediate question to be resolved. This should be addressed transparently, in compliance with the Deed, informed by professional expertise and open to public view, rather than left to a process that offers no indication of how such selections would be made. We have attached an advisory note on how this could be done, directed at the governmental membership of the AGC.
What this will require of both parties
None of this will happen while the City and the Friends continue to treat this as a contest to be won rather than a problem to be solved. The City has too often met legitimate concern with delay and insufficient transparency, placing the retention of control above the delivery of results. The Friends and the Johannesburg Heritage Foundation have too often reached for public campaigns, and for serious and unsubstantiated allegations and legal threats in place of the patient work of building a transparent, fully costed project with shared ownership — and they owe the public the same standard of openness about their own governance and finances that they ask of others.
We invite all who care about the future of the Johannesburg Art Gallery to add their names in support below.
Initial signatories
Pfunzo Sidogi, Molemo Moiloa, Nontobeko Ntombela, Joseph Gaylard
former independent members, Art Gallery Committee