top of page

FAQs

This section provides more context, though still a brief and high-level overview. For each issue we outline where things stand, how they got there, and how this compares with accepted museum practice.

​

Connected to these are a number of documents for the record for transparency and perusal.

Much public commentary has drawn on unclear standards, outdated assumptions about how museums operate, and unsubstantiated claims, while overlooking some of the significant issues that would really make a difference. We have tried to ground our statements in documentation anyone can access: these are in a public folder, and further sources are given in the endnotes.

​

We have said little in public until now, and deliberately so. Our position throughout has been that the Gallery’s problems should be resolved through direct engagement, not through lawyers or media campaigns. We speak now because misinformation has filled that silence, and because the institution needs plain speaking about honesty, transparency and accountability, from everyone involved, including ourselves.

​

In what follows, “the Friends” refers to the Friends of the Johannesburg Art Gallery, and “the applicants” to the Friends together with the Johannesburg Heritage Foundation, who jointly brought the current court application against the City.

Frequently asked questions

Notes

[1] Letter from the independent members to the Office of the Executive Mayor suspending participation and setting out conditions for return, July 2025. LINK

​

[2] The Municipal Finance Management Act and the Municipal Systems Act, read together, pose a number of constraints and complexities with regard to the manner in which municipalities can transact with external entities around the delivery of services - this has implications both for the donation of services, and for regularised ongoing partnerships with external organisations. These questions are thoughtfully explored in a Daily Maverick Op-ed by Sean Gossel and Thomas Koelble from 2021, as well as a two part advisory note from the Dullah Omar Institute; see Part 1 and Part 2. This has both immediate and longer term implications for JAG which warrant fuller treatment than is possible here.

​

[3] City of Johannesburg Museum Loan Policy

​

[4] See September 2022 Letter addressed to Councillor Harris [LINK] and 2024 letter addressed to the Mayor [LINK]

​

[5] ICOM Code of Ethics for Museums, section 1 (institutional standing, governance and delegation).

​

[6]see the Cultural Institutions Act 119 of 1998, which provides for councils governing declared national cultural institutions.

​

[7] These reports include the Aphane Wiew Conservation Management Plan (2013); Engela White, conservation report (2015); Jonathan Stone, audit and Conservation Management Plan (2017); SAJ Architects, Conditions Assessment for the JDA (2021, presented March 2022); SAJ Architects, further architectural work for the JDA (2023); Lamela/Mayat Hart surveys (2025/26). 

​

[8] See for example the Burra Charter (Australia ICOMOS, 2013), a widely used standard for the conservation of heritage places, which treats maintenance as fundamental to conservation.

​

[9] ICOM Working Group on Collections in Storage, Museum Storage around the World (May 2024). https://icom.museum/en/?p=58235.

​

[10] ICOM Code of Ethics for Museums, section 1 (institutional standing, governance and delegation). https://icom.museum/en/resources/standards-guidelines/code-of-ethics/

​

[11] National Heritage Resources Act 25 of 1999, administered by SAHRA, which regulates the export and movement of heritage objects. https://www.sahra.org.za

 

[12] The theft of crown jewels from the Louvre, Paris, in October 2025.  See also the following for a sample of wider analysis on the Louvre and British Museum incidents:

The Louvre Heist Was a Colonial Wake up Call;

Fix Cataloguing, Governance, Security and HR: Apart from that the British Museum is Fine, Review Finds; 

Review into British Museum thefts calls for fundamental reforms

​

[13] the City's position is outlined in correspondence from their attorneys in March 2026 to the Friends [LINK] in response to a February letter in which the case is reiterated for Ditsong as a temporary relocation site for the collection [LINK].

​

[14] for more info see World Federation of Friends of Museums (WFFM) website and the WFFM Code of Ethics;

 

[15] Friends of Glasgow Museums, Constitution

​

[16] This foundational misunderstanding appears in their 2024 letter of demand :"the JAG was entrusted to the City of Joburg ("COJ") as the custodian of the art collection, whilst the Art Gallery Committee is responsible for managing the collection ..." (emphasis added). In their 2025 ReJAG proposal they repeat this foundational error, again referring to the Committee as "collection manager".

​

[17] These issues are thoughtfully explored in a Daily Maverick Op-ed by Sean Gossel and Thomas Koelble from 2021, as well as a two part advisory note from the Dullah Omar Institute; see Part 1 and Part 2. This has both immediate and longer term implications for JAG outlined in more detail in a short advisory note we have prepared which can be found here.

​

[18] Notice of motion and founding papers, Johannesburg High Court, May 2026. Webber Wentzel Notice of Motion and Founding Affidavit; ENS Supplementary Affidavit;  Webber Wentzel Supplementary Affidavit

​

[19] Affidavit of Professor Federico Freschi, filed with the applicants’ papers. Freschi Affidavit

​

[20] In this regard, see the important research and advocacy work of the civil society initiative VAR DBN (Visual Arts Revolution Durban): VAR DBN Final Report & Recommendations on DAG.docx 

bottom of page